Bataille Empire - Test Game

 

Bataille Empire Solo Game Report

Introduction

I have recently become a convert to ADLG so I therefore thought I must try Bataille Empire (BE). All my figures for Napoleonics are 6mm. Therefore I hummed and hawed for a while on what UD should be given my troops are based on 25mm frontage bases. For this game I chose 1UD=25mm, a small change from the BE standard but it seemed to work well.

Force Selection

The troops I chose were for the 1809 Danube Campaign French vs Austrians.

 


 


I am still a little confused and concerned about representative scales to be able to refight real battles.

It seems when playing that the units more appropriately represent brigade and regimental level rather than battalions and cavalry regiments. Even so the ground scale does not really reflect this scale, nor does the amount of artillery. Specifically, I am concerned about artillery scale in the game as in spite of the rules recommending certain numbers of artillery per unit per nation the final allocation seems a little light and does not reflect real engagements.

I think a little more clarity on ground scale and unit scale for the rules to allow historical refights would not go amiss.

All that have being said. The overall points balance and force mix I chose gave a good game.

Terrain Selection

I quite like the terrain selection rules. They seem to work well. I think however, that the variety of ground across Europe for the campaigns needs a little more detail. The terrain in the Danube Valley in 1809 is very different from Flanders at the same time! Therefore having different terrain selections for campaigns might not be a bad addition to the rules. In 1809 around Regensburg in the Danube Valley I would have expected to encounter more woods than I did!

The Battle

Initial Setup

With the dice rolls I generated an encounter battle. This shows the starting point for game turn 1

Both sides had one division deployed.



Game Turn 1

The French move to secure the village as an objective. Meanwhile the Austrians Advance Guard Division advances with engage orders to secure the field.

 


Game Turn 2

The French division attacking the Village manages to secure half of the village. Poor command dice prevents them occupying the entire village. Meanwhile their Light Cav Division has arrived with engage orders to protect the left flank of the attack on the village.

The Austrians continue to advance to engage their objective. In doing so they confront the two flanking French Regiments and punish them with fire disordering them both. The Austrian 1st Division has arrived with attack orders to secure the village.

 


Game Turn 3

The French 1st Division orders are changed to hold, the disordered regiments rally. On the left flank the Austrian Light Cavalry charges and is counter-charged by the French. The French are beaten back and the Austrian Cavalry withdraw to their cannons.

In the centre the Austrian 1st Division has good command and control and manages to make a double move to its objective.

The French 2nd Division has arrived and moves fast with engage orders to their objective the hill in the Austrian position.

The Austrian 2nd Division has arrived to hold the Buildings.

 


Game Turn 4

The French in the village throwback the initial Austrian assault. The cavalry reengage this time the French win the combat.

French 2nd Division’s orders are changed to attack the Building and the Austrians around it. With good command and control they manage a triple move to close on the Austrians before they can adequately react. The Austrian 2nd Division’s command and control is very poor.

 




Game Turn 5

The Austrian’s second assault succeeds and the French are driven out of the village. While the French 2nd Division’s first assault on the Austrian 2nd Division is thrown back in retreat. The Austrian 2nd Division Commander brings his reserve regiment around the village, but they are caught in the flank by the French 12lbs.

The third engagement between the two cavalry forces sees the Austrians come of best and destroying both French Regiments in the pursuit.

 



Game Turn 6

The French 2nd Division has successfully charged and destroyed an Austrian Regiment. The Flanking regiment is again punished by the French artillery and retires disordered.

The French 1st Division orders are changed to withdraw, to save casualties.

The Austrian Advance Guard has secured its objectives. Poor command and control has prevented the Grenzer regiments supporting the cavalry on the objective.

On counting all the casualties, the Austrian force has 21.5 and the French 10. The Austrians suffer a crushing defeat, despite taking their objective, and would have had to retire to their right rear away from their lines of communications.

 

Conclusion

On balance I can live with these rules. They are quite fun and give a good game.

One of the things I mangled in the rules was, if you look closely, that the large Austrian regiments were not in the correct column formation. Here I think a one element wide column makes more sense, but not according to the rules. It might have made a little difference in the attack in the centre, but not hugely so.

The other is that I am not sure I played the cavalry charges exactly to the rules, but I think the outcome would have been the same.

The large Austrian regiments are resilient, but require a lot of space in which to deploy.

The Austrian poor command and control makes them very challenging to play with.

I like the feel of these rules in 6mm scale. It feels like a Corps level engagement with the units representing regiments. Next time I think I will revert to 3cm per UD I am not sure that the odd 5mm makes that much sense; not least because once the forces were deployed I remembered that my cavalry are based on 3cm frontage!

I think I would like more terrain on the battlefield.

 

2 comments:

  1. The Austrians lost?? How unrealistic is that... :D :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Agreed, quite realistic, but it was interesting how close the French came to a defeat in this simple game - hence the decision to break of the 1st French Division

      Delete

ADLG - Game Report 9

ADLG - Thessalian (60) vs Graeco-Bactrian (46) A Socially Distanced Garden Game with Paul Frith While we wait patiently for the lockdown res...